| YEAR | CHAMPION | FINALIST |
| 1926 | Cleveland Rosenblums | Brooklyn Arcadinas |
| 1927 | Brooklyn Original Celtics | Rochester Centrals |
| 1928 | New York Original Celtics | Fort Wayne Hoosiers |
| 1929 | Cleveland Rosenblums | Fort Wayne Hoosiers |
| 1930 | Cleveland Rosenblums | Rochester Centrals |
| 1931 | Brooklyn Visitations | Fort Wayne Hoosiers |
| 1934 | Philadelphia Sphas | Trenton Moose |
| 1935 | Brooklyn Visitations | New York Jewels |
| 1936 | Philadelphia Hebrews | Brooklyn Visitations |
| 1937 | Philadelphia Hebrews | Jersey Reds |
| 1938 | Jersey Reds | New York Jewels |
| 1939 | New York Jewels | Jersey Reds |
| 1940 | Philadelphia Colonials | Washington Brewers |
| 1941 | Philadelphia Sphas | Brooklin Celtics |
| 1942 | Wilmington Blue Bombers | |
| 1943 | Philadelphia Sphas | Trenton Tigers |
| 1944 | Wilmington Blue Bombers | Philadelphia Sphas |
| 1945 | Philadelphia Sphas | Baltimore Bullets |
| 1946 | Baltimore Bullets | Philadelphia Sphas |
| 1947 | Baltimore Bullets | Brooklyn Gothams |
| 1948 | Wiles-Barre Barons | Paterson Crescents |
| 1949 | Wiles-Barre Barons | Scranton Miners |
| 1950 | Scranton Miners | Bridgeport Aer-A-Sols |
| 1951 | Scranton Miners | |
| 1952 | Wiles-Barre Barons | Scranton Miners |
| 1953 | Manchester British Americans | Wiles-Barre Barons |
| 1962 | Cleveland Pipers | Kansas City Steers |
| 1963 | Kansas City Steers |