| YEAR | CHAMPION | FIRST HALF | SECOND HALF |
| 1912 | Troy Trojans | ||
| 1913 | Troy Trojans | ||
| 1914 | Utica Indians | ||
| 1915 | Troy Trojans | ||
| 1916 | Schenectady | ||
| 1917 | Schenectady | ||
| 1920 | Albany Senators and Troy | Albany Senators | Troy |
| 1921 | Albany | Albany | Albany |
| 1922 | Cohoes | Gloversville | Cohoes |
| 1923 | Kingston Colonials | Kingston Colonials | Kingston Colonials |